What does the artistic idea of a work mean? What is the idea of a work
Subject
Subject
(Greek theme - what is supposed to be), in literary criticism - the content of a work in its most general view or the content of any fragment of the work. In the literature of antiquity, the Middle Ages, Renaissance And classicism the topic of the essay was strictly related to his genre. Thus, the exploits of kings and generals were narrated in epic poems; their deeds were praised in solemn odah; the conflict between man and fate or the struggle between duty and passion was depicted in tragedies, A human vices were exposed in comedies. In the era romanticism the clear correlation between genre and theme was destroyed; it was preserved only in some genres. For example, idyll- a short poetic work about the simple joys of rural life, and elegy – lyric poem sad content about lost youth and disappointed hopes. Various literary trends and currents (see Literary direction and current) have preference different topics. In classicism it is heroic themes, themes of service to the state, in romanticism - love theme, themes of loneliness, death, etc., in symbolism– religious and mystical themes.
Literature and language. Modern illustrated encyclopedia. - M.: Rosman. Edited by prof. Gorkina A.P. 2006 .
SUBJECT- the main idea, the main sound of the work. Representing that indecomposable emotional-intellectual core that the poet seems to be trying to decompose with each of his works, the concept of theme is by no means covered by the so-called. content. The theme in the broad sense of the word is that complete image world, which determines the artist’s poetic worldview. Under the sign of this image, the artist combines the most diverse phenomena of reality. Thanks to this image, the synthetic activity of the artist is possible, which distinguishes him from the non-artist.
Every artist has his own theme, his own image of the world.
But depending on the material through which this image is refracted, we have one or another reflection of it, i.e. one or another idea (a specific theme) that defines this particular work, where only one of the faces of the single image guiding the artist’s entire work is revealed. If, from this point of view, we approach, approximately, Lermontov, whose main theme is the Demon, then we can outline a number of particular themes that determined one or another plot of his individual works. The theme of a demon seeking salvation through love defines the plot of “The Demon”; theme of a demon stooping to human image, - the plot of “A Hero of Our Time,” etc. The concept of the theme will become even more prominent if we compare it with musical concept leit-motif, with what is usually called, when applied to a literary work, the “red thread”. Since a well-known theme, the main idea, influences the significance of a particular moment and individual moments are perceived against the background of the thematic whole, one can, of course, talk about a “red thread” running through the entire work. But at the same time, the concept of theme is by no means covered by the concept of “leit motif” or “red thread”. While the leit-motif, the guiding motive, runs through the entire work, then in the form of repetitions (repetition of the same sounds, thoughts, repetition of positions characters, repetition of descriptions in general or in particular, etc.), then in the form of different variations - if the leit-motif and the “red thread” clearly breaks through here and there, connecting individual parts - the theme itself remains outwardly unidentified, forming a mental center around which everything is located, but which is not fixed in any single phrase. For this reason, it seems completely incorrect definition themes of a well-known work only by one or another technique and repeating moment, for the theme runs through in every moment, it is everywhere and nowhere, as someone noted when applied to music, which can be extended to literature. A theme can only repeat itself, and its development lies in these repetitions. Proof of the validity of this thought is both the work of great writers in general (Lermontov’s theme is the demon, Tyutchev’s theme is the struggle between the day and night principles, etc.), and their individual works.
J. Zundelovich.
Subject. This is sometimes the name given to the derived verb stem of the common Indo-European language. on O, alternating with e, Wed Greek φέρομεν “we carry” (μεν - the end of the 1st l. plural), φέρετε “you carry” (τε - the end of the 2nd l. plural); most vowel sounds O, e at the end of T. called. thematic vowels, and the conjugation of verbs from T. to oh - thematic conjugation(cm.).
N.D. Literary Encyclopedia: Dictionary literary terms: In 2 volumes / Edited by N. Brodsky, A. Lavretsky, E. Lunin, V. Lvov-Rogachevsky, M. Rozanov, V. Cheshikhin-Vetrinsky. - M.; L.: Publishing house L. D. Frenkel, 1925
Synonyms:
See what “theme” is in other dictionaries:
subject- y, w. theme, German Thema gr. theme installed; position. 1. The range of life phenomena, events that make up the content of a work of literature, painting, etc. or that underlie scientific research, report, etc. BAS 1. Here’s a topic for you... Historical Dictionary Gallicisms of the Russian language
Subject- THEME is the main idea, the main sound of the work. Representing that indecomposable emotionally intellectual core that the poet seems to be trying to decompose with each of his works, the concept of theme is by no means covered by the so-called... ... Dictionary of literary terms
- (lat. theme). 1) content. 2) the main idea of the essay. 3) in music: the main motive that must be developed by the composer. Dictionary of foreign words included in the Russian language. Chudinov A.N., 1910. TOPIC [gr. theme] linguistic with current... ... Dictionary of foreign words of the Russian language
TOPIC, themes, women. (Greek theme). 1. The subject of some kind of reasoning or presentation. Essay on the topic of the Napoleonic Wars. Choose collective farm life as the theme of the story. “Let me tell you a small incident on this topic.” Leskov. ||… … Ushakov's Explanatory Dictionary
Cm … Synonym dictionary
- “THEME”, USSR, Mosfilm, 1979, color, 99 min. Psychological drama. The “theme” stated in the previous film by director Gleb Panfilov “I Ask for the Word” found a direct continuation in this film. Panfilov exposes deep research… … Encyclopedia of Cinema
TOPIC (in philosophy and history of science) a term introduced by J. Holton as key concept thematic analysis. The term “theme” is used by Holton in three different aspects: thematic concepts, hypotheses and methodologies. Holton doesn't... Philosophical Encyclopedia
Subject- [from the Greek thema, literally what is put (as the basis)], 1) the subject of description, research, conversation, etc. 2) In art (literature, theater, cinema, painting) an object artistic image, a circle of life phenomena captured in... ... Illustrated encyclopedic Dictionary
Proposal, subject of discussion, development task; Main thought. Wed. “We won’t talk about this topic, we’re talking about the mother.” And in general, let’s drop all topics for now. Au revoir. A. A. Sokolov. Secret. 20. Wed. He... private letters...... ... Michelson's Large Explanatory and Phraseological Dictionary (original spelling)
TOPIC, s, women. 1. Subject, main content of reasoning, presentation, creativity. Move to another topic. T. story. 2. Main motive piece of music. T. with variations. | adj. thematic, aya, oe (to 1 meaning). The thematic line of the novel... Ozhegov's Explanatory Dictionary
Female, Greek a proposal, position, task that is being discussed or explained. | Melody, tune, musical. Dahl's Explanatory Dictionary. IN AND. Dahl. 1863 1866 … Dahl's Explanatory Dictionary
Books
- Topic 1. Part 1. Food, products, in a restaurant (DVD), Bystrova Marina. Topic 1. Part 1. Increase your vocabulary quickly! DVD cards + usage examples + voice-over (Russian-English). Food, groceries, in a restaurant. Learn Russian words in a quick way! DVD...
1. Topic, themes, problems of the work.
2. The ideological concept of the work.
3. Pathos and its varieties.
Bibliography
1. Introduction to literary criticism: textbook / ed. L.M. Krupchanov. – M., 2005.
2. Borev Yu.B. Aesthetics. Theory of literature: encyclopedic dictionary of terms. – M., 2003.
3. Dal V.I. Explanatory Dictionary of the Living Great Russian language: in 4 volumes. – M., 1994. – Vol.4.
4. Esin A.B.
5. Literary encyclopedic dictionary / ed. V.M. Kozhevnikova, P.A. Nikolaeva. – M., 1987.
6. Literary encyclopedia of terms and concepts / ed. A.N. Nikolyukina. – M., 2003.
7. Soviet encyclopedic dictionary / ch. ed. A.M. Prokhorov. – 4th ed. – M., 1989.
Literary scholars rightly argue that what gives a literary work its holistic character is not the hero, but the unity of the problem posed in it, the unity of the idea being revealed. Thus, in order to delve deeper into the content of the work, it is necessary to determine its components: theme and idea.
"Subject ( Greek. thema), - according to V. Dahl’s definition, - a proposal, position, task that is being discussed or explained.”
The authors of the Soviet Encyclopedic Dictionary give the topic a slightly different definition: “The topic [what is the basis] is 1) the subject of description, image, research, conversation, etc.; 2) in art, an object of artistic depiction, a range of life phenomena depicted by a writer, artist or composer and held together by the author’s intention.”
In dictionary literary terms“We find the following definition: “Theme is what is the basis literary work, the main problem posed by the writer in it" .
In the textbook “Introduction to Literary Studies,” ed. G.N. Pospelov's theme is interpreted as an object of knowledge.
A.M. Gorky defines a theme as an idea, “which originated in the author’s experience, is suggested to him by life, but nests in the receptacle of his impressions still unformed and, demanding embodiment in images, arouses in him the urge to work on its design.”
As you can see, the above definitions of the topic are diverse and contradictory. The only statement with which one can agree without reservation is that the topic is truly the objective basis of any work of art. We have already talked above about how the process of birth and development of a theme occurs, how a writer studies reality and selects life phenomena, what is the role of the writer’s worldview in the selection and development of a theme ( see the lecture “Literature is a special kind artistic activity person").
However, the statements of literary scholars that the theme is a circle of life phenomena depicted by the writer, in our opinion, are not comprehensive enough, since there are differences between the life material (the object of the image) and the theme (subject matter) of the work of art. The subject of depiction in works of fiction can be a variety of phenomena. human life, life of nature, animal and flora, and material culture(buildings, settings, views of cities, etc.). Sometimes even fantastic creatures are depicted - talking and thinking animals and plants, various kinds of spirits, gods, giants, monsters, etc. But this is by no means the topic of a literary work. Images of animals, plants, and views of nature often have an allegorical and auxiliary meaning in a work of art. They either represent people, as happens in fables, or are created to express human experiences (in lyrical images of nature). Even more often, natural phenomena with its flora and fauna are depicted as the environment in which human life with its social character takes place.
When defining a theme as vital material taken for depiction by a writer, we must reduce its study to the analysis of the objects depicted, and not the characteristic features of human life in its social essence.
Following A.B. Yesin, under topic literary work we will understand " object of artistic reflection , those life characters and situations (relationships of characters, as well as human interaction with society as a whole, with nature, everyday life, etc.), which seem to move from reality into a work of art and form the objective side of its content ».
The theme of a literary work covers everything depicted in it and therefore can be comprehended with the necessary completeness only on the basis of penetration into all the ideological and artistic richness of this work. For example, to determine the theme of the work by K.G. Abramov "Purgaz" ( unification of the Mordovian people, fragmented into many often warring clans at the end of the 12th - early XIII centuries, contributing to the salvation of the nation, the preservation of its spiritual values), it is necessary to take into account and comprehend the multilateral development of this topic by the author. K. Abramov also shows how the character of the main character was formed: the influence of the life and national traditions of the Mordovian people, as well as the Volga Bulgars, among whom, by the will of fate and his own desire, he had the opportunity to live for 3 years, and how he became the head of the clan how I struggled with Vladimir princes and the Mongols because of their dominance in the western part of the Middle Volga region, what efforts were made to ensure that the Mordovian people became united.
In the process of analyzing the topic, it is necessary, according to the authoritative opinion of A.B. Yesin, firstly, to distinguish between reflection object(topic) and image object(the specific situation depicted); secondly, it is necessary distinguish between concrete historical and eternal themes. Specific historical themes are characters and circumstances born and conditioned by a certain socio-historical situation in a particular country; they are not repeated beyond a given time, they are more or less localized (for example, the theme “ extra person"in Russian literature of the 19th century). When analyzing a specific historical topic, one must see not only the socio-historical, but also the psychological certainty of character, since comprehension of character traits helps to correctly understand the unfolding plot and the motivation for its twists and turns. Eternals themes capture recurring moments in the history of various national societies, they are repeated in different modifications in the lives of different generations, in different historical eras. These are, for example, the themes of love and friendship, life and death, relationships between generations and others.
Due to the fact that the topic requires various aspects of consideration, along with its general concept, the concept is also used topics, i.e. those lines of development of the theme that are outlined by the writer and constitute its complex integrity. Close attention to the diversity of topics is especially necessary when analyzing major works, in which there is not one, but many topics. In these cases, it is advisable to highlight one or two main topics related to the image central character, or a number of characters, and treat the rest as side characters.
When analyzing the content of a literary work great importance has a definition of its problems. In literary criticism, the problematics of a literary work are usually understood as the area of comprehension, the writer’s understanding of the reflected reality: « Issues (Greek. problema – something thrown forward, i.e. isolated from other aspects of life) – this is the writer’s ideological understanding of the social characters that he depicted in the work. This comprehension consists in the fact that the writer highlights and strengthens those properties, aspects, relationships of the characters depicted, which he, based on his ideological worldview, considers the most significant.”
In works of art that are large in volume, writers, as a rule, pose a variety of problems: social, moral, political, philosophical, etc. It depends on what aspects of the characters and what contradictions of life the writer focuses on.
For example, K. Abramov in the novel “Purgaz”, through the image of the main character, understands the policy of uniting the Mordovian people, scattered into numerous clans, however, the disclosure of this problem (socio-political) is quite closely connected with the moral problem (refusal of the woman he loved, the order to kill Tengush , one of the leaders of the clan, etc.). Therefore, when analyzing a work of art, it is important to understand not only the main problem, but also the entire problem as a whole, to identify how deep and significant it is, how serious and significant are the contradictions of reality that the writer depicted.
One cannot but agree with the statement of A.B. Esin that the problems contain the author’s unique view of the world. Unlike the topic, the problematic is the subjective side artistic content, therefore, the author’s individuality, “the author’s original moral attitude to the subject,” is maximally manifested in it. Often different writers create works on the same topic, however, there are no two major writers whose works would coincide in their problematics. The uniqueness of the issue is unique business card writer.
For practical analysis of the problem, it is important to identify the originality of the work, comparing it with others, to understand what makes it unique and unique. For this purpose, it is necessary to establish in the work under study type problems.
Main types of problems in domestic literary criticism were identified by G.N. Pospelov. Based on the classification of G.N. Pospelov, taking into account the current level of development of literary criticism A.B. Esin proposed his own classification. He singled out mythological, national, novel, sociocultural, philosophical problems. In our opinion, it makes sense to highlight the issues moral .
Writers not only pose certain problems, they look for ways to solve them, relate what they depict to social ideals. Therefore, the theme of a work is always connected with its idea.
N.G. Chernyshevsky, in his treatise “Aesthetic Relations of Art to Reality,” speaking about the tasks of art, asserts that works of art “reproduce life, explain life and pass judgment on it.” It is difficult to disagree with this, since works of fiction always express the ideological and emotional attitude of writers to topics social characters which they depict. The ideological and emotional assessment of the characters depicted is the most active aspect of the content of the work.
"Idea (Greek. idea – idea, prototype, ideal) in literature - expression author's attitude to what is depicted, the correlation of this depicted with the ideals of life and man affirmed by writers“, - this definition is given in the “Dictionary of Literary Terms”. We find a somewhat refined version of the definition of an idea in the textbook by G.N. Pospelova: “ The idea of a literary work is the unity of all aspects of its content; this is a figurative, emotional, generalizing thought of the writer, manifested in choice, and in comprehension, and in the assessment of characters ».
When analyzing a work of art, identifying an idea is very important and significant for the reason that the idea is progressive, corresponding to the course of history, trends social development, is a necessary quality of all truly artistic works. Understanding the main idea of a work should follow from an analysis of its entire ideological content(the author's assessment of events and characters, the author's ideal, pathos). Only under this condition can we correctly judge him, his strength and weakness, the nature and roots of the contradictions in him.
If we talk about K. Abramov’s novel “Purgaz”, then the main idea that the author expresses can be formulated as follows: the strength of the people lies in their unity. Only by uniting all the Mordovian clans, Purgaz, as a talented leader, was able to resist the Mongols and liberate the Mordovian land from the conquerors.
We have already noted that the themes and issues of artistic works must meet the requirements of depth, relevance and significance. The idea, in turn, must meet the criteria of historical truthfulness and objectivity. It is important for the reader that the writer expresses such an ideological and emotional understanding of the portrayed characters, which these characters are truly worthy of in terms of the objective, essential properties of their lives, in terms of their place and significance in national life in general, in the prospects for its development. Works that contain a historically true assessment of the phenomena and characters depicted are progressive in their content.
The primary source of artistic ideas in reality, according to I.F. Volkov, are “only those ideas that entered the artist’s flesh and blood, became the meaning of his existence, his ideological and emotional attitude to life.” V.G. Belinsky called such ideas pathos . “A poetic idea,” he wrote, “is not a syllogism, not a dogma, not a rule, it is a living passion, it is pathos.” Belinsky borrowed the very concept of pathos from Hegel, who in his lectures on aesthetics used the word “pathos” to mean ( Greek. pathos - a strong, passionate feeling) the artist’s high enthusiasm for comprehending the essence of the life depicted, its “truth”.
E. Aksenova defines pathos this way: “Pathos is an emotional animation, a passion that permeates a work (or its parts) and gives it a single breath - what can be called the soul of a work. In pathos, the artist’s feeling and thought form a single whole; it contains the key to the idea of the work. Pathos is not always and not necessarily bright expressed emotion; This is where it shows up most clearly creative individuality artist. Along with the authenticity of feelings and thoughts pathos imparts liveliness and artistic persuasiveness to a work and is a condition for its emotional impact on the reader " Pathos is created by artistic means: the depiction of characters, their actions, experiences, events in their lives, and the entire figurative structure of the work.
Thus, pathos is the writer’s emotional and evaluative attitude towards the person depicted, characterized by great strength of feelings .
In literary criticism, the following main types of pathos are distinguished: heroic, dramatic, tragic, sentimental, romantic, humorous, satirical.
Heroic pathos affirms the greatness of the feat of an individual and an entire team, its enormous significance for the development of a people, a nation, and humanity. Figuratively revealing the main qualities of heroic characters, admiring them and praising them, the artist of words creates works imbued with heroic pathos (Homer “Iliad”, Shelley “Prometheus Unchained”, A. Pushkin “Poltava”, M. Lermontov “Borodino”, A. Tvardovsky "Vasily Terkin"; M. Saigin "Hurricane", I. Antonov "In a United Family").
Dramatic pathos characteristic of works that depict dramatic situations that arise under the influence of external forces and circumstances that threaten the desires and aspirations of the characters, and sometimes their lives. Drama in works of art can be both ideologically affirming pathos, when the writer deeply sympathizes with the characters (“The Tale of the Ruin of Ryazan by Batu”), and ideologically negating, if the writer condemns the characters of his characters in the drama of their situation (Aeschylus “Persians”).
Quite often, the drama of situations and experiences arises during military clashes between nations, and this is reflected in works of fiction: E. Hemingway “A Farewell to Arms”, E.M. Remarque “A Time to Live and a Time to Die”, G. Fallada “Wolf Among Wolves”; A. Bek “Volokolamsk Highway”, K. Simonov “The Living and the Dead”; P. Prokhorov “We Stood” and others.
Often writers in their works depict the drama of the situation and experiences of the characters, which arises due to social inequality people (“Père Goriot” by O. Balzac, “The Humiliated and Insulted” by F. Dostoevsky, “Dowry” by A. Ostrovsky, “Tashto Koise” (“According to Old Customs”) by K. Petrova, etc.
Often the influence of external circumstances gives rise to internal contradiction in a person’s mind, a struggle with himself. IN in this case the drama deepens to the point of tragedy.
Tragic pathos its roots are connected with tragic character conflict in a literary work, caused by the fundamental impossibility of resolving existing contradictions, and is most often present in the genre of tragedy. Reproducing tragic conflicts, writers depict the painful experiences of their heroes, difficult events in their lives, thereby revealing the tragic contradictions of life, which have a socio-historical or universal character (W. Shakespeare “Hamlet”, A. Pushkin “Boris Godunov”, L. Leonov “Invasion”, Y. Pinyasov “Erek ver” (“Living Blood”).
Satirical pathos. Satirical pathos is characterized by the denial of negative aspects public life and character traits of people. The tendency of writers to notice the comic in life and reproduce it on the pages of their works is determined primarily by the properties of their innate talent, as well as by the peculiarities of their worldview. Most often, writers pay attention to the discrepancy between people's claims and real capabilities, which results in the development of comical life situations.
Satire helps you realize important aspects human relationships, gives orientation in life, frees from false and outdated authorities. In world and Russian literature there are a lot of talented, highly artistic works with satirical pathos, including: the comedies of Aristophanes, “Gargantua and Pantagruel” by F. Rabelais, “Gulliver’s Travels” by J. Swift; “Nevsky Prospekt” by N. Gogol, “The History of a City” by M. Saltykov-Shchedrin, “ dog's heart"M. Bulgakov). IN Mordovian literature no significant work with clearly expressed satirical pathos has yet been created. Satirical pathos is characteristic primarily of the fable genre (I. Shumilkin, M. Beban, etc.).
Humorous pathos. Humor emerged as a special type of pathos only in the era of romanticism. Due to false self-esteem, people not only in public, but also in everyday life and family life may discover internal contradictions between who they really are and who they say they are. These people pretend to be important, which they actually do not have. Such a contradiction is comical and evokes a mocking attitude, mixed more with pity and sadness than with indignation. Humor is laughter at the relatively harmless comic contradictions of life. A striking example of a work with humorous pathos is the story “ Posthumous notes The Pickwick Club" by Charles Dickens; “The Tale of How Ivan Ivanovich Quarreled with Ivan Nikiforovich” by N. Gogol; “Lavginov” by V. Kolomasov, “An agronomist came to the collective farm” (“An agronomist came to the collective farm” by Yu. Kuznetsov).
Sentimental pathos characteristic primarily of sentimental works created in the 18th century, characterized by exaggerated attention to the feelings and experiences of the heroes, depiction of moral virtues socially humiliated people, their superiority over the immorality of a privileged environment. As bright examples the works “Julia, or the new Heloise” by J.J. Rousseau, “The Sorrows of Young Werther” by I.V. Goethe, " Poor Lisa» N.M. Karamzin.
Romantic pathos conveys the spiritual enthusiasm that arises as a result of identifying a certain sublime principle and the desire to identify its features. Examples include the poems of D.G. Byron, poems and ballads by V. Zhukovsky and others. In Mordovian literature, works with clearly expressed sentimental and romantic pathos are absent, which is largely due to the time of the emergence and development of written literature (the second half of the 19th century).
CONTROL QUESTIONS:
1. What definitions of theme take place in literary criticism? Which definition do you think is most accurate and why?
2. What are the problems of a literary work?
3. What types of problems do literary scholars distinguish?
4. Why is identifying issues considered an important step in the analysis of works?
5. What is the idea of a work? How is it related to the concept of pathos?
6. What types of pathos are most often found in works of native literature?
Lecture 7
PLOT
1. The concept of plot.
2. Conflict as the driving force of plot development.
3. Plot elements.
4. Plot and plot.
Bibliography
1) Abramovich G.L. Introduction to literary criticism. – 7th ed. – M., 1979.
2) Gorky A.M.. Conversations with young people (any publication).
3) Dobin E.S. Plot and reality. The art of detail. – L., 1981.
4) Introduction to literary criticism / ed. G.N. Pospelov. – M., 1988.
5) Esin A.B. Principles and techniques of analyzing a literary work. – 4th ed. – M., 2002.
6) Kovalenko A.G.. Artistic conflict in Russian literature. – M., 1996.
7) Kozhinov V.V.. Plot, plot, composition // Theory of literature: Main problems in historical coverage: in 2 books. – M., 1964. – Book 2.
8) Literary encyclopedic dictionary / ed. V.M. Kozhevnikova, P.A. Nikolaev. – M., 1987.
9) Literary encyclopedia of terms and concepts / ed. A.N. Nikolyukina. – M., 2003.
10) Shklovsky V.B.. Energy of delusion. Book about the plot // Favorites: in 2 volumes - M., 1983. - Volume 2.
11) Brief literary encyclopedia: in 9 t/hl. ed. A.A. Surkov. – M., 1972. – T.7.
It is well known that a work of art is a complex whole. The writer shows how this or that character grows and develops, what are his connections and relationships with other people. This development of character, the history of growth, is shown in a series of events, which, as a rule, reflect the life situation. Direct relationships between people presented in a work, shown in a certain chain of events, in literary criticism are usually designated by the term plot.
It should be noted that the understanding of plot as the course of events has a long tradition in Russian literary criticism. It developed back in the 19th century. This is evidenced by the work of the outstanding literary critic, representative of the comparative-historical school in Russian literary criticism of the 19th century A.N. Veselovsky "Poetics of Plots".
The problem of plot has occupied researchers since Aristotle. G. Hegel also paid much attention to this problem. Despite such long history, the problem of the plot remains largely debatable to this day. For example, there is still no clear distinction between the concepts of plot and plot. In addition, the definitions of plot found in textbooks and teaching aids on literary theory are different and quite contradictory. For example, L.I. Timofeev considers the plot as one of the forms of composition: “Composition is inherent in every literary work, since we will always have in it one or another relationship of its parts, reflecting the complexity of the life phenomena depicted in it. But not in every work we will deal with a plot, i.e. with the revelation of characters through events in which the properties of these characters are revealed... One should reject the widespread and erroneous idea of plot only as a distinct, fascinating system of events, due to which they often talk about the “non-plot” of certain works in which there is no such clarity and fascination of the system of events (actions). Here we're talking about not about the absence of a plot, but about its poor organization, ambiguity, etc.
The plot in a work is always present when we are dealing with certain actions of people, with certain events that happen to them. By connecting the plot with the characters, we thereby determine its content, its conditionality by the reality that the writer is aware of.
Thus, we approach both composition and plot as a means of revealing, discovering a given character.
But in a number of cases, the general content of the work does not fit into the plot alone and cannot be revealed only in the system of events; hence - along with the plot - we will have extra-plot elements in the work; the composition of the work will then be broader than the plot and will begin to manifest itself in other forms.”
V.B. Shklovsky considers the plot as a “means of understanding reality”; in the interpretation of E.S. Dobin, the plot is a “concept of reality.”
M. Gorky defined the plot as “connections, contradictions, sympathies, antipathies and, in general, relationships between people - stories of growth and organization of one or another character, type.” This judgment, like the previous ones, in our opinion, is not accurate, because in many works, especially dramatic ones, characters are depicted outside the development of their characters.
Following A.I. Revyakin, we tend to adhere to this definition of the plot: « A plot is an event (or system of events) selected in the process of studying life, realized and embodied in a work of art, in which conflict and characters are revealed in certain conditions of the social environment».
G.N. Pospelov notes that literary subjects are created in different ways. Most often, they fairly fully and reliably reproduce real life events. These are, firstly, works based on historical events (« Early years King Henry IV" by G. Mann, "The Damned Kings" by M. Druon; “Peter I” by A. Tolstoy, “War and Peace” by L. Tolstoy; “Polovt” by M. Bryzhinsky, “Purgaz” by K. Abramov); Secondly, autobiographical stories(L. Tolstoy, M. Gorky); Thirdly, known to the writer life facts . The events depicted are sometimes completely the writer’s fiction, a figment of the author’s imagination (“Gulliver’s Travels” by J. Swift, “The Nose” by N. Gogol).
There is also such a source of plot creativity as borrowing, when writers widely rely on already known literary plots, processing and supplementing them in their own way. In this case, folklore, mythological, ancient, biblical, etc. subjects are used.
Home driving force any plot is conflict, contradiction, struggle or, according to Hegel's definition, collision. The conflicts underlying works can be very diverse, but they, as a rule, have general significance and reflect certain life patterns. Conflicts are distinguished: 1) external and internal; 2) local and substantial; 3) dramatic, tragic and comic.
Conflict external – between individual characters and groups of characters – is considered to be the simplest. There are many examples of this type of conflict in the literature: A.S. Griboyedov “Woe from Wit”, A.S. Pushkin “The Miserly Knight”, M.E. Saltykov-Shchedrin “The History of a City”, V.M. Kolomasov "Lavginov" and others. A more complex conflict is considered to be one that embodies the confrontation between the hero and the way of life, the individual and the environment (social, everyday, cultural). The difference from the first type of conflict is that the hero here is not opposed by anyone in particular; he has no opponent with whom he could fight, who could be defeated, thereby resolving the conflict (Pushkin “Eugene Onegin”).
Conflict interior - a psychological conflict, when the hero is not at peace with himself, when he carries certain contradictions within himself, sometimes contains incompatible principles (Dostoevsky “Crime and Punishment”, Tolstoy “Anna Karenina”, etc.).
Sometimes in a work one can simultaneously detect both of these types of conflict, both external and internal (A. Ostrovsky “The Thunderstorm”).
Local(resolvable) conflict presupposes the fundamental possibility of resolution through active actions (Pushkin “Gypsies”, etc.).
Substantial(unresolvable) conflict depicts a persistently conflicted existence, and real practical actions capable of resolving this conflict are unthinkable (Shakespeare's Hamlet, Chekhov's The Bishop, etc.).
Tragic, dramatic and comic conflicts are inherent in dramatic works with similar genre names. (For more information about the types of conflicts, see the book A.G. Kovalenko “Artistic conflict in Russian literature”, M., 1996).
Disclosure of a socially significant conflict in the plot contributes to the understanding of trends and patterns of social development. In this regard, it is worth noting some points that are essential for understanding the multifaceted role of the plot in the work.
The role of plot in the work of G.L. Abramovich defined it as follows: “Firstly, it must be borne in mind that the artist’s penetration into the meaning of the conflict presupposes, as the modern English writer D. Lindsay, “penetration into the souls of people participating in this struggle.” Hence the great educational significance of the plot.
Secondly, the writer “willy-nilly becomes involved with his mind and heart in the conflicts that make up the content of his work.” Thus, the logic of the development of events by the writer is reflected in his understanding and assessment of the depicted conflict, his public views, which he one way or another conveys to readers, instilling in them the necessary, from his point of view, attitude towards this conflict.
Thirdly, every great writer focuses his attention on conflicts that are important for his time and people.”
Thus, the plots of the works of great writers have a deep socio-historical meaning. Therefore, when considering them, it is necessary first of all to determine which one social conflict lies at the heart of the work and from what positions it is depicted.
The plot will only fulfill its purpose when, firstly, it is internally complete, i.e. revealing the causes, nature and development paths of the depicted conflict, and secondly, it will attract the interest of readers and force them to think about the meaning of each episode, each detail in the movement of events.
F.V. Gladkov wrote that there are different gradations of plot: “... one book has a plot calm, there is no intrigue or cleverly tied knots in it, it is a chronicle of the life of one person or a whole group of people; another book with exciting plot: these are adventure novels, mystery novels, detective novels, criminal novels.” Many literary scholars, following F. Gladkov, distinguish two types of plots: the plot is calm (adynamic) and the plot is sharp(dynamic). Along with the named types of plots, modern literary criticism offers others, for example, chronic and concentric (Pospelov G.N.) and centrifugal and centripetal (Kozhinov V.V.). Chronicles are stories with a predominance of purely temporary connections between events, and concentric - with a predominance of cause-and-effect relationships between events.
Each of these types of plots has its own artistic possibilities. As noted by G.N. Pospelov, the chronicle of the plot is, first of all, a means of recreating reality in the diversity and richness of its manifestations. Chronic plotting allows the writer to master life in space and time with maximum freedom. Therefore it is widely used in epic works large shape(“Gargantua and Pantagruel” by F. Rabelais, “Don Quixote” by M. Cervantes, “Don Juan” by D. Byron, “Vasily Terkin” by A. Tvardovsky, “ Wide Moksha"T. Kirdyashkina, "Purgaz" by K. Abramov). Chronicle stories perform different artistic functions: reveal the decisive actions of the heroes and their various adventures; depict the formation of a person’s personality; serve to master the socio-political antagonisms and everyday life of certain strata of society.
The concentricity of the plot - identifying cause-and-effect relationships between the events depicted - allows the writer to explore one conflict situation and stimulates the compositional completeness of the work. This type of plot structure dominated drama until the 19th century. Among the epic works, one can cite as an example “Crime and Punishment” by F.M. Dostoevsky, “Fire” by V. Rasputin, “At the Beginning of the Path” by V. Mishanina.
Chronicle and concentric plots often coexist (“Resurrection” by L.N. Tolstoy, “Three Sisters” by A.P. Chekhov, etc.).
From the point of view of the emergence, development and completion of the life conflict depicted in the work, we can talk about the main elements of plot construction. Literary scholars identify the following plot elements: exposition, plot, development of action, climax, peripeteia, denouement; prologue and epilogue. It should be noted that not all works of fiction that have a plot structure contain all the designated plot elements. Prologue and epilogue are found quite rarely, most often in epic works that are large in volume. As for exposition, it is quite often absent from stories and novellas.
Prologue defined as an introduction to a literary work that is not directly related to the developing action, but seems to precede it with a story about the events that preceded it or about their meaning. The prologue is present in I. Goethe’s Faust, “What is to be done?” N. Chernyshevsky, “Who Lives Well in Rus'” by N. Nekrasov, “The Snow Maiden” by A. Ostrovsky, “Apple Tree at high road» A. Kutorkina.
Epilogue in literary criticism it is characterized as the final part in a work of art, reporting future fate heroes after those depicted in a novel, poem, drama, etc. events. Epilogues are often found in the dramas of B. Brecht, novels by F. Dostoevsky (“The Brothers Karamazov”, “The Humiliated and Insulted”), L. Tolstoy (“War and Peace”), K. Abramov “Kachamon Pachk” (“Smoke on the Ground” ).
Exposition (lat. expositio - explanation) call the background to the events underlying the work. The exposition sets out the circumstances, preliminarily outlines the characters, characterizes their relationships, i.e. The life of the characters before the start of the conflict (commencement) is depicted.
In the work of P.I. Levchaev’s “Kavonst kudat” (“Two Matchmakers”), the first part is an exposition: it depicts the life of a Mordovian village shortly before the first Russian revolution, the conditions in which people’s characters are formed.
Exposure is determined artistic tasks work and can be different in nature: direct, detailed, scattered, supplemented throughout the entire work, delayed (see “Dictionary of Literary Terms”).
Tie-up in a work of fiction, it is usually called the beginning of a conflict, the event from which the action begins and thanks to which subsequent events arise. The beginning can be motivated (if there is exposition) or sudden (without exposition).
In P. Levchaev’s story, the plot will be Garay’s return to the village of Anay, his acquaintance with Kirei Mikhailovich.
In subsequent parts of the work, Levchaev shows action development, That course of events that follows from the plot: meeting with his father, with his beloved girl Anna, matchmaking, Garay’s participation in a secret meeting.
The gasoline is yours, the ideas are ours
When analyzing a literary work, the concept of “idea” is traditionally used, which most often means the answer to the question allegedly posed by the author.
The idea of a literary work - this is the main idea that summarizes the semantic, figurative, emotional content of a literary work.
Artistic idea of the work – this is the content-semantic integrity of a work of art as a product of emotional experience and mastery of life by the author. This idea cannot be recreated by means of other arts and logical formulations; it is expressed throughout artistic structure work, the unity and interaction of all its formal components. Conventionally (and in a narrower sense), an idea stands out as the main thought, ideological conclusion and “life lesson” that naturally follows from a holistic comprehension of the work.
An idea in literature is a thought contained in a work. There are a great many ideas expressed in literature. Exist logical ideas And abstract ideas . Logical ideas are concepts that are easily conveyed without figurative means; we are able to perceive them with our intellect. Logical ideas are characteristic of nonfiction literature. Fictional novels and stories are characterized by philosophical and social generalizations, ideas, analyzes of causes and consequences, that is, abstract elements.
But there is also a special type of very subtle, barely perceptible ideas in a literary work. Artistic idea is a thought embodied in figurative form. It lives only in figurative transformation and cannot be expressed in the form of sentences or concepts. The peculiarity of this thought depends on the disclosure of the topic, the author’s worldview, conveyed by the speech and actions of the characters, and on the depiction of pictures of life. It lies in the combination of logical thoughts, images, and all significant compositional elements. An artistic idea cannot be reduced to a rational idea that can be specified or illustrated. The idea of this type is integral to the image, to the composition.
Forming an artistic idea is difficult creative process. In literature it is influenced personal experience, the writer’s worldview, understanding of life. An idea can be nurtured for years and decades, and the author, trying to realize it, suffers, rewrites the manuscript, and looks for suitable means of implementation. All themes, characters, all events selected by the author are necessary for a more complete expression of the main idea, its nuances and shades. However, it is necessary to understand that artistic idea not equal ideological plan, that plan that often appears not only in the writer’s head, but also on paper. Exploring extra-artistic reality, reading diaries, notebooks, manuscripts, archives, literary scholars restore the history of the idea, the history of creation, but often do not discover the artistic idea. Sometimes it happens that the author goes against himself, yielding to the original plan for the sake of artistic truth, an internal idea.
One thought is not enough to write a book. If you know in advance everything that you would like to talk about, then you should not turn to artistic creativity. Better - to criticism, journalism, journalism.
The idea of a literary work cannot be contained in one phrase and one image. But writers, especially novelists, sometimes struggle to formulate the idea of their work. Dostoevsky about “The Idiot” he wrote: “The main idea of the novel is to portray positively wonderful person" For such a declarative ideology Dostoevsky scolded, for example, Nabokov. Indeed, the phrase of the great novelist does not clarify why, why he did it, what is the artistic and vital basis of his image. But here you can hardly take sides Nabokov, a down-to-earth second-line writer, never, unlike Dostoevsky who does not set himself creative super-tasks.
Along with the attempts of authors to determine the so-called main idea of their work, opposite, although no less confusing, examples are known. Tolstoy to the question “what is “War and Peace”? answered as follows: ““War and Peace” is what the author wanted and could express in the form in which it was expressed.” Reluctance to translate the idea of your work into the language of concepts Tolstoy demonstrated once again, speaking about the novel “Anna Karenina”: “If I wanted to say in words everything that I had in mind to express in a novel, then I would have to write the very one that I wrote first” (from a letter to N.Strakhov).
Belinsky very accurately pointed out that “art does not allow abstract philosophical, much less rational ideas: it allows only poetic ideas; A poetic idea- This<…>It’s not a dogma, it’s not a rule, it’s a living passion, pathos.”
V.V. Odintsov expressed his understanding of the category “artistic idea” more strictly: “The idea of a literary work is always specific and is not directly derived not only from the individual statements of the writer lying outside it (facts of his biography, social life, etc.), but also from the text - from replicas goodies, journalistic inserts, comments by the author himself, etc.”
2000 ideas for novels and stories
Literary critic G.A. Gukovsky also spoke about the need to distinguish between rational, that is, rational, and literary ideas: “By idea I mean not only a rationally formulated judgment, statement, not even just the intellectual content of a work of literature, but the entire sum of its content, constituting its intellectual function, its goal and task.” And he further explained: “To understand the idea of a literary work means to understand the idea of each of its components in their synthesis, in their systemic interconnection.<…>. At the same time, it is important to take into account structural features works - not only the words-bricks from which the walls of the building are made, but the structure of the combination of these bricks as parts of this structure, their meaning.”
The idea of a literary work is an attitude towards what is depicted, the fundamental pathos of the work, a category that expresses the author’s tendency (inclination, intention, preconceived thought) in the artistic coverage of a given topic. In other words, idea is the subjective basis of a literary work. It is noteworthy that in Western literary criticism, based on other methodological principles, instead of the category “artistic idea”, the concept of “intention”, a certain premeditation, the tendency of the author to express the meaning of the work is used.
The greater the artistic idea, the longer the work lives. The creators of pop literature who write outside of great ideas face very rapid oblivion.
V.V. Kozhinov called it an artistic idea semantic type works that grow from the interaction of images. An artistic idea, unlike a logical idea, is not formulated by an author’s statement, but is depicted in all the details of the artistic whole.
In epic works, the idea may be partly formulated in the text itself, as was the case in the narrative Tolstoy: “There is no greatness where there is no simplicity, goodness and truth.” More often, especially in lyric poetry, the idea permeates the structure of the work and therefore requires great analytical work. A work of art as a whole is much richer than the rational idea that critics usually isolate, and in many lyrical works isolating an idea is simply impossible, because it practically dissolves in pathos. Consequently, the idea of a work should not be reduced to a conclusion or a lesson, and in general one should certainly look for it.
When analyzing a work, along with the concepts of “theme” and “problematics”, the concept of idea is also used, by which most often we mean the answer to the question allegedly posed by the author.
Ideas in literature can be different. An idea in literature is a thought contained in a work. There are logical ideas, or concepts. A logically formulated general thought about a class of objects or phenomena; idea of something The concept of time, which we are able to perceive with the intellect and which are easily conveyed without figurative means. Novels and stories are characterized by philosophical and social generalizations, ideas, analyzes of causes and consequences, and a network of abstract elements.
But there is a special type of very subtle, barely perceptible ideas in a literary work. An artistic idea is a thought embodied in figurative form. It lives only in figurative transformation and cannot be expressed in the form of sentences or concepts. The peculiarity of this thought depends on the disclosure of the topic, the author’s worldview, conveyed by the speech and actions of the characters, and on the depiction of pictures of life. It lies in the combination of logical thoughts, images, and all significant compositional elements. An artistic idea cannot be reduced to a rational idea that can be specified or illustrated. The idea of this type is integral to the image, to the composition.
Forming an artistic idea is a complex creative process. It is influenced by personal experience, the writer’s worldview, and understanding of life. An idea can be nurtured for years; the author, trying to realize it, suffers, rewrites, and searches for adequate means of implementation. All themes, characters, all events are necessary for a more complete expression of the main idea, its nuances, shades. However, it is necessary to understand that an artistic idea is not equal to an ideological plan, that plan that often appears not only in the writer’s head, but also on paper. By exploring extra-artistic reality, reading diaries, notebooks, manuscripts, archives, scientists restore the history of the idea, the history of creation, but do not discover the artistic idea. Sometimes it happens that the author goes against himself, yielding to the original plan for the sake of artistic truth, an internal idea.
One thought is not enough to write a book. If you know in advance everything you would like to talk about, then you should not turn to artistic creativity. Better - to criticism, journalism, journalism.
The idea of a literary work cannot be contained in one phrase and one image. But writers, especially novelists, sometimes struggle to formulate the idea of their work. Dostoevsky said about “The Idiot”: “The main idea of the novel is to portray a positively beautiful person.” Dostoevsky F.M. Collection of works: In 30 volumes. T. 28. Book 2. P.251.. But Nabokov did not accept him for this same declarative ideology. Indeed, the novelist’s phrase does not clarify why, why he did it, what is the artistic and vital basis of his image.
Therefore, along with cases of defining the so-called main idea, other examples are known. Tolstoy’s answer to the question “What is “War and Peace”? answered as follows: ““War and Peace” is what the author wanted and could express in the form in which it was expressed.” Tolstoy demonstrated his reluctance to translate the idea of his work into the language of concepts once again, speaking about the novel “Anna Karenina”: “If I wanted to say in words everything that I had in mind to express in a novel, then I would have to write the very one that I wrote first” (letter to N. Strakhov).
Belinsky very accurately pointed out that “art does not allow abstract philosophical, much less rational ideas: it allows only poetic ideas; and the poetic idea is<…>not a dogma, not a rule, it is a living passion, pathos” (lat. pathos - feeling, passion, inspiration).
V.V. Odintsov expressed his understanding of the category of artistic idea more strictly: “The idea of a literary work is always specific and is not directly derived not only from the individual statements of the writer lying outside it (facts of his biography, social life, etc.), but also from the text - from replicas positive characters, journalistic inserts, comments from the author himself, etc.” Odintsov V.V. Stylistics of the text. M., 1980. S. 161-162..
Literary critic G.A. Gukovsky also spoke about the need to distinguish between rational, that is, rational, and literary ideas: “By idea I mean not only a rationally formulated judgment, statement, not even just the intellectual content of a work of literature, but the entire sum of its content, which constitutes its intellectual function, its goal and task" Gukovsky G.A. Studying a literary work at school. M.; L., 1966. P.100-101.. And further explained: “To understand the idea of a literary work means to understand the idea of each of its components in their synthesis, in their systemic interconnection<…>At the same time, it is important to take into account the structural features of the work - not only the words-bricks from which the walls of the building are made, but the structure of the combination of these bricks as parts of this structure, their meaning” Gukovsky G.A. P.101, 103..
O.I. Fedotov, comparing the artistic idea with the theme, the objective basis of the work, said the following: “An idea is an attitude towards what is depicted, the fundamental pathos of a work, a category that expresses the author’s tendency (inclination, intention, preconceived thought) in the artistic coverage of a given topic.” Consequently, the idea is the subjective basis of the work. It is noteworthy that in Western literary criticism, based on other methodological principles, instead of the category of artistic idea, the concept of intention, a certain premeditation, the tendency of the author to express the meaning of the work is used. This is discussed in detail in the work of A. Companion “The Demon of Theory” Companion A. The Demon of Theory. M., 2001. pp. 56-112. In addition, in some modern domestic studies, scientists use the category “creative concept”. In particular, it sounds in textbook edited by L. Chernets Chernets L.V. A literary work as an artistic unity // Introduction to literary criticism / Ed. L.V. Chernets. M., 1999. P. 174..
The more majestic the artistic idea, the longer the work lives.
V.V. Kozhinov called an artistic idea a semantic type of work that grows out of the interaction of images. Summarizing the statements of writers and philosophers, we can say that thin. An idea, in contrast to a logical idea, is not formulated by an author’s statement, but is depicted in all the details of the artistic whole. The evaluative or value aspect of a work, its ideological and emotional orientation is called a tendency. In the literature of socialist realism, the tendency was interpreted as partisanship.
In epic works, the ideas may be partly formulated in the text itself, as in Tolstoy's narrative: “There is no greatness where there is no simplicity, goodness and truth.” More often, especially in lyric poetry, the idea permeates the structure of the work and therefore requires a lot of analytical work. A work of art as a whole is richer than the rational idea that critics usually isolate. In many lyrical works, isolating an idea is untenable, because it practically dissolves in pathos. Consequently, the idea should not be reduced to a conclusion, a lesson, and one should certainly look for it.
Any analysis of a literary work begins with identifying its theme and idea. There is a close semantic and logical connection between them, thanks to which the literary text is perceived as an integral unity of form and content. A correct understanding of the meaning of the literary terms theme and idea allows us to determine how accurately the author was able to realize his creative plan and whether his book is worth the reader’s attention.
The theme of a literary work is a semantic definition of its content, reflecting the author’s vision of the depicted phenomenon, event, character or other artistic reality.
An idea is a writer’s plan, pursuing a specific goal in creating artistic images, using the principles of plot construction and achieving the compositional integrity of a literary text.
What is the difference between a theme and an idea?
Figuratively speaking, a theme can be considered any reason that prompted the writer to take up the pen and transfer it to Blank sheet paper reflected in artistic images perception of the surrounding reality. You can write about anything; another question: for what purpose, what task should I set myself?
The goal and task determine the idea, the disclosure of which constitutes the essence of an aesthetically valuable and socially significant literary work.
Among the diversity literary themes There are several main directions that serve as guidelines for the flight of the writer’s creative imagination. These are historical, social, everyday, adventure, detective, psychological, moral and ethical, lyrical, philosophical themes. The list goes on. It will include original author's notes, literary diaries, and stylistically refined extracts from archival documents.
The theme, felt by the writer, acquires spiritual content, an idea, without which book page will remain just coherent text. The idea can be reflected in a historical analysis of problems important to society, in the depiction of complex psychological moments on which human destiny, or simply in creating a lyrical sketch that awakens a sense of beauty in the reader.
The idea is the deep content of the work. Theme is a motive that allows you to realize a creative idea within a specific, precisely defined context.
The difference between a topic and an idea
The theme determines the actual and semantic content of the work.
The idea reflects the tasks and goals of the writer, which he strives to achieve while working on a literary text.
The theme has formative functions: it can be revealed in small literary genres or be developed into a major epic work.
The idea is the main content core literary text. It corresponds to the conceptual level of organization of the work as an aesthetically significant whole.
(No ratings yet)
Essays on topics:
- The story “Mowers” is a poetic sketch accompanied by the writer’s reflections on the fate of his people. The reason for writing the story was the writer heard...
- The novel “Doctor Zhivago” by B. L. Pasternak found its reader not so long ago, because Soviet officials for a long time considered it forbidden...
- In 1835, the collection “Arabesques” was published in St. Petersburg, in which Nikolai Gogol’s story “Scraps from the Notes of a Madman” was published. She...
- Myths are found in the folklore of all peoples of the world. The roots of the word “myth” stretch back to ancient Greece - it means “tradition, legend”....